Why Do Superhero Films Struggle with Action Scenes?

In the realm of action cinema, few moments resonate quite like the tension of a hero running barefoot through shards of glass, fearlessly confronting the enemy. This iconic dynamic, seen in films like Die Hard, captures the essence of what makes action stories compelling. But when it comes to modern superhero films, a disconnect often occurs, diluting the impact of action sequences. Chad Stahelski, the visionary behind the John Wick franchise, sheds light on this critical issue, emphasizing the need for a unified approach to storytelling and action.

The Dance of Action and Narrative

In a revealing interview with THR, Stahelski articulates his views on the shortcomings plaguing the superhero genre. He argues that many superhero movies, particularly those from Marvel and DC, frequently employ second unit directors for action scenes. This segregation creates a chasm between the narrative and the physicality onscreen. “The story doesn’t stop just because there’s punching and kicking,” he asserts, pointing out that a seamless blend of action and storytelling is essential for authenticity.

It’s not just about the spectacle; it’s about emotional engagement. Stahelski argues that even the most choreographed action sequences can fall flat without character investment. “You could execute the same choreography as in John Wick, but if audiences didn’t love Keanu Reeves in the role, we wouldn’t be discussing it now,” he reflects. This highlights a vital truth: audiences crave connection, and action must serve the overarching narrative rather than overshadow it.

Mastering the Medium

Stahelski draws comparisons to legends like Jackie Chan, recognizing that while technical skill is essential, the heart of the story is equally critical. The industry’s dichotomy, where some believe action should overshadow narrative and vice versa, must be reconciled. By treating the film as a cohesive unit—where every punch, kick, and narrative twist enhances and informs the other—directors can craft more resonant experiences.

As Stahelski notes, filmmakers like Steven Spielberg and Christopher Nolan are deeply involved in their action sequences, ensuring that every moment on-screen is aligned with the film’s emotional landscape. This artistic integrity is what sets apart memorable films from forgettable ones. It’s a lesson that superhero filmmakers might well take to heart if they wish to deliver a more immersive cinematic experience.

In a landscape filled with visually stunning but emotionally barren action, Stahelski’s insights remind us that true impact lies in a story well-told—one that embraces both heart and action. As audiences await upcoming releases, the hope remains that superhero films will evolve, learning from the best in the business.