The buzz around the new iPhone 17 Pro, Pro Max, and iPhone Air has been hard to miss, particularly following concerns about the devices appearing scratched in stores. But fear not—Apple has addressed these worries head-on, clarifying that it’s not a design issue but rather a problem with old MagSafe display stands.
Apple confirmed that the marks can be easily wiped away, effectively putting an end to the so-called “scratchgate.” However, not all scratching is the same, and there’s a specific concern regarding the anodized coating around the camera plateau. Videos from tech enthusiasts like Zach Nelson on YouTube have demonstrated how the coating may chip when subjected to pressure, leading to some skepticism.
What Makes the iPhone 17 Pro Stand Out?
The iPhone 17 Pro and Pro Max sport bodies made from aerospace-grade 7000 series aluminum and feature both Ceramic Shield and the newly introduced Ceramic Shield 2. This material is touted to be four times more resistant to cracks compared to its predecessor, the iPhone 16 Pro.
Ceramic Shield, composed of nano-crystals in a glass matrix, covers most of the 17 Pro’s back. Apple claims that it enhances durability significantly, while the new Ceramic Shield 2 for the display offers three times the scratch resistance of the Classic Ceramic Shield.
During the latest announcement event, Apple emphasized that the Ceramic Shield is primarily focused on impact resistance, while the newer version aims to improve scratch durability. This is a game changer for users who prioritize a scratch-free experience.
Analyzing the Anodized Coating Issue
Zach Nelson’s video on the iPhone 17 Pro raises eyebrows about the anodized coating’s quality, particularly at the camera plateau’s edges. Nelson points to a lack of adherence to international standards, specifically regarding the radius threshold for decorative anodizing.
He suggests that the flat edges, especially where the coating meets sharp corners, are susceptible to chipping. This presents a visual change that may concern users, particularly with darker colors that reveal the underlying aluminum when damaged.
Nelson also notes an apparent weakness in the lack of chamfers or fillets around the camera plateau, making it easier for the anodized finish to chip under pressure. While he acknowledges the robust nature of the coating against light scratches, the edges remain vulnerable.
Insights from iFixIt on Spalling
iFixIt’s teardown of the iPhone 17 Pro supports Nelson’s claims. Lead technician, Shahram Mokhtari, demonstrated that the anodized coating peels off at the sharp edges, a phenomenon referred to as “spalling.” This occurs when pressure is applied to the brittle oxide layer, causing it to chip.
Mokhtari also emphasized that the basic iPhone 17 and the iPhone Air don’t suffer from the same level of vulnerability, as their backs consist of glass or Ceramic Shield, offering a more durable alternative.
Durability of the iPhone 17 Pro and iPhone Air
The consensus appears to be that the iPhone 17 Pro and iPhone Air are durable, but users should take precautions. While normal wear-and-tear may lead to small abrasions, these won’t affect the phone’s operation. To preempt chipping, investing in a good case is advisable.
Although the sheer aesthetics of the iPhone 17 Pro are appealing, prioritizing the longevity of the anodized finish may require extra care. Users can feel confident in the device’s overall robustness while being aware of its potential weak points.
If you discover scratches or damage, your best bet is to return the device to the retailer, especially if it seems like it was caused during use. However, if the scratches were indeed the result of typical handling, then a case becomes essential for future protection.