Is Big Jake the Best Underrated John Wayne Western?

Picture thithe dust of the American West kicks up under the pounding hooves of a horse, a silhouette against the setting sun. This is merely a glimpse of Big Jake, a film that may not have dominated box offices in its time but has risen to capture the hearts of Western aficionados everywhere. Tucked in the archives of Amazon Prime, this lesser-known gem from John Wayne’s later career has found its rightful place among his finest works.

Though it never garnered the same critical acclaim as his earlier masterpieces, Big Jake has accumulated a devoted following over the years, now ranking sixth on IMDb’s “Best John Wayne Films” list. Fans hail it as one of the most binge-worthy Westerns of its era, highlighting the film’s intriguing blend of tension and camaraderie.

Set in the turbulent backdrop of 1909, the story follows Jacob McCandles—better known as Big Jake. After his grandson is abducted by a ruthless outlaw gang led by John Fain (portrayed by Richard Boone), Big Jake embarks on an intense, perilous journey. The ensuing cross-country rescue is packed with gritty gunfights, dust-strewn trails, and, of course, John Wayne’s trademark grit that fans adore.

Behind the Camera and Cast

Directed by George Sherman, who closed a significant chapter of his 30-year career with this film, Big Jake also features the last screen appearance of Maureen O’Hara alongside Wayne. Their long-standing chemistry lends added depth to the narrative, marking an emotional highlight in her final role before a two-decade-long retirement. The cast is further enriched by Wayne’s son Patrick Wayne, Christopher Mitchum, and notable Western veterans like Harry Carey Jr. and Hank Worden, creating a tapestry of character that only Westerns can offer.

Critics offered a mixed bag of reviews upon the film’s release. While some, like The New York Times, recognized the film’s exciting finale and urged viewers to “stick it out” through what they described as “a long prelude,” others found fault with its excessive violence. The Chicago Tribune called the violence gratuitous but believed there was potential for a stronger film. Meanwhile, Variety praised the film’s script and cinematography, despite acknowledging a leaning towards “gratuitous” depictions of violence.

In more forgiving terms, The Los Angeles Times deemed it “a typical John Wayne Western,” emphasizing the film’s tried-and-true mix of action and humor that clearly satisfied fans. However, critics from The Washington Post expressed concern that Wayne’s dominating presence overshadowed the younger talents involved.

Regardless of the varying critiques, Wayne’s magnetism shone through. As noted by The Monthly Film Bulletin, Big Jake stands as “another genial celebration of Big John’s ability to carry a film practically single-handed.” Financially, the film performed admirably, grossing $7.5 million in the U.S., a considerable feat for a Western of its time.

Over the years, Big Jake has only solidified its legacy. It enjoys strong fan rankings and a cherished spot in IMDb’s top John Wayne features. For those who appreciate classic Westerns, this film is not just another entry; it is a rich tapestry of grit, family, and the relentless pursuit of justice, embodying the essence of what makes Westerns endure.

With its gripping narrative and compelling performances, Big Jake remains available to stream on Amazon Prime, waiting for a new generation of viewers to discover its gritty charm.